“A Little M/Mothman Romance,” Fiction, TJ West

Autumn is Leo’s favorite time of the year. He loves everything about it: the scents of apple and pumpkin spice in the air; the way that the trees turned into a riot of color on the West Virginia hills; the way that mornings were crisp and cool, perfect for wandering over the fields.

And, of course, he loves the Mothman Festival.

Every year, he makes the trip into Point Pleasant for the second day, even going so far as to rent a hotel room in the local Days Inn. He wanders through the vendors that always set up shop, and of course he makes his yearly pilgrimage to the Mothman Museum. He’s done it so many times that most of the vendors and the folks who work at the museum know him by name, and they smile and wave and chat with him a bit, even as they’re also respectful of his desire for space. 

At the end of the day, after the last bus tour has finished its rounds, he also goes out to the  old TNT Area (or, to give it its proper name, the McClintic Wildlife Management Area). This is ground zero for sightings of Mothman and, while he’s never seen the creature himself, he holds out hope that one day he will.

There’s only one fly in the ointment when it comes to the day of the Mothman Festival. Even though the whole town celebrates that day, there are always a few skeptics who roll in thinking that they’re going to be able to make fun of the locals and who go out of their way to pretend that Mothman doesn’t exist at all. Leo usually tries to avoid those people, because he knows there’s no point in getting into an argument with nonbelievers.

Until, that is, he met Eric. Or perhaps met isn’t the right word, since they’ve never been properly introduced. Even so, Leo knows everything he needs to know about the man he’s decided is his nemesis.

In fact, he’s always known that Eric was trouble. Every year he turns up with his polo shirt and his khakis and his loafers, with that signature smirk on his face that says very clearly that he’s better than everyone around him. Leo’s always thought he looks like a Young Republican, even though they’re both probably in their thirties. He also looks like he has a stick shoved up his ass, which is very much on brand with most of the Young Republicans that Leo’s known over the years.

Even Leo has to admit, though, that Eric is handsome, too, with his coal-black hair, his jawline that could cut glass, and his steely blue eyes. In fact, he’s so attractive that Leo also knows that he doesn’t like him. In his experience, you can never trust someone that handsome, particularly when they’re also someone who doesn’t believe in Mothman and thinks that anyone who does is worthy of all kinds of mockery, both online and in the real world.

Eric is always there with his iPhone, recording little interviews with attendees for his YouTube channel. He always makes it seem like he’s asking questions in good faith, that he really does want to understand what the locals see in the whole Mothman thing. Leo knows, though, that he has a more sinister motive. He once made the mistake of going to said YouTube channel, only to find out that Eric was making fun of all of the people that he’d interviewed while he was in Point Pleasant. 

The fact that Eric isn’t just someone dick from out-of-state makes things that much worse. He might be from the Northern Panhandle–and thus just barely a West Virginian at all–but he’s still a Mountaineer. Which means, of course, that he should know better than to make fun of people from the Mountain State. That’s one of those things that you just don’t do. West Virginians should stick together, not tear each other down.

As he makes the short drive into town, Leo knows for sure that he’s going to see Eric, because he always does. No matter how hard he tries to avoid him–and he often tries very, very hard to do just that–somehow the two of them always end up next to each other.

Sure enough, as soon as Leo gets his car parked and starts to walk toward downtown, he sees Eric standing across the street and, as always, he feels that familiar tug of attraction. No matter how hard he tries to push it away, he can’t help but be aware of just how handsome Eric is, with his hair all meticulously styled, his meticulous (in fact downright fussy) fashion sense, and the way that he is so tall that he seems to loom over everyone else around him.

You’ve got to get him out of your head, Leo reprimands himself with a shake. He’s a dick and an interloper. And he’s a skeptic. You can do better than that.   

Eric looks in his direction and he tries to avoid his gaze. Too late, though, he realizes that he’s done the worst thing you can do with a person like that: he’s made eye contact. When he looks back up Eric is actually crossing the street toward him, that trademark smirk on his face. They might never have formally met, but they’ve had a few ugly exchanges on the comments section of Eric’s YouTube channel. Leo isn’t particularly proud of some of the more…assertive…things he’s said on there, but neither is he going to apologize.

“So, fuckericsyoutubechannel, we actually meet in the real world,” Eric says. Even his voice is smarmy, and it makes Leo want to punch him.

“Yeah,” he mumbles, not even bothering to look up, “I guess we do.” Then he asks. “How did you know it was me?”

Eric just laughs. “You think I haven’t noticed the way that you glare at me every time I come to town? I knew as soon as you started to drop those comments on my channel that there was only one person that it could be. You know, I gotta give you credit. You really stand up for your fellow Mothman enthusiasts. You’re really a true believer.”

It’s at this that Leo actually looks up. Unless he’s mistaken, he actually heard something other than mockery from Eric, which is the last thing he would have expected. In fact, Eric is looking at him with something dangerously like speculation, as if he’s trying to figure out how he can make use of his true believer status.

“What do you want?” He spits the words out. He’s learned the hard way that you shouldn’t trust people like Eric. They’re only too happy to make fools of everyone else if they think it’ll get them more clout or influence.

Rather than responding in anger to that unmistakable bit of rudeness, Eric just smiles again.

“I guess it’s actually refreshing that you’re as prickly in real life as you are on the internet. It means that you are who you say you are.”

Leo isn’t sure what to do with this compliment from the person that he has come to regard as his worst enemy, and so he doesn’t say anything. He just turns his attention back to the asphalt and kicks aimlessly at the ground.

“I was actually wondering,” Eric goes on, as if he’s totally ignorant of the fact that he’s making Leo very uncomfortable. “If you wanted to go on a little expedition to the TNT Area. I’ve never been there, let alone with someone like you, who thinks that Mothman really exists. I think it’d be fun. And it’d give my subscribers something new to watch rather than the same old boring interviews.”

“You’ve got to be fucking kidding, right?” Leo says. He doesn’t really mean to be so rude, but it’s beyond ridiculous for someone like Eric to be asking him to go on a monster-hunting mission when they both know that he’s just going to use this as an excuse to make a fool of Leo. If there’s one thing that Leo refuses to be, for anyone, it’s a fool.

“No,” he says. “Forget it. Not gonna happen.”

He almost relishes the downfallen look on Eric’s face. Did he really think that his smooth talking and his charm was going to work?

You know, it wouldn’t be so bad to just try it, right? I mean, you’re going to spend the evening at the TNT area, anyway. Why not drag this skeptic along and show him that there really is a good reason to believe in the Mothman?

In fact, the more he thinks about this, the more convinced Leo becomes that this is exactly the thing that he should do. Truth be told he relishes the thought of tormenting Eric by forcing him to walk through the swampy grounds of the TNT Area.

That’ll show this smartass, he thinks.

“Okay, fine,” he says. “Stop looking like a beaten puppy. I’ll do it.” He pauses meaningfully. “But we’re going to enjoy the Festival itself for a while before we go off on this little adventure of yours. This is my favorite part of the year, and I’m certainly not going to waste it for you.”

Eric shrugs his shoulders. Now that he’s gotten what he wants he doesn’t feel the need to press. They’ll be heading off soon enough, so surely he can tolerate some time at the Mothman Festival.

 

They wander the streets of Point Pleasant for a good couple of hours after that, and Leo finds himself swept up in the sense of excitement that he always feels at this time of the year. Normally he likes spending most of his time by himself–he’s a textbook introvert, and he’s very okay with that–but at least for today he enjoys being in the rush of people. There are people dressed up as Mothman, with as many different ideas for what the creature looks like as there are people to make the costume, and there are more than a few television crews there. Unless he’s mistaken, one of them is actually from some big TV network or other.

Mothman continues to be big business.

He also sees several of the same people that he encounters every year. Some are people from Point Pleasant and its environs, but others are from places further afield, from Huntington and Charleston and elsewhere in West Virginia. There are even a few from out-of-state and out of the country, and he stops and chats with them for a few minutes, catching up with what they’ve been doing.

The whole time he’s doing this Eric doesn’t say much of anything. He just sort of lurks in the background, but Leo has the distinct feeling that he’s jotting all of this down on some notepad in his mind, no doubt accumulating a whole series of embarrassing and amusing anecdotes that he can use for one of his damn videos.

“You know, I gotta hand it to you,” he says at last, “you’re much more involved with this group than I would have thought. You seem to know almost everyone here.”

Leo sniffs. “Well, that tends to happen when you actually get to know people rather than just ambushing them and using them to boost your own career.”

He hadn’t really meant for the words to come out like that, but now that they are he’s aware of how bitter and angry he sounds.

“You’re really pissed about this, aren’t you?”

Leo pinches his nose between two of his fingers. It’s the thing that he always does when he feels the anger boiling up inside him and threatening to spill out. He knows  that he’s probably just being paranoid, but he can’t shake the feeling that everyone here is looking at him and just waiting for him to explode.

Just keep taking deep breaths, he reminds himself. And you’ll get calmed down again.

It takes a bit longer than it usually does, but it finally works.

“You know, you don’t have to be quite so bitter and angry about everything,” Eric says. There’s no trace of judgment in his voice. Instead, it’s as if he’s genuinely trying to figure out just what it is that Leo’s doing, why he seems so angry all the time.

If I could figure that out I’d probably be a lot happier, he thinks sourly.

However, he doesn’t want to confront this whole situation right now. Right now what he wants is just to enjoy the Mothman Festival and not have Eric breathing down his neck at every moment.

“Let’s go to the Mothman Museum,” he says, and before Eric can protest (though he does give Leo a very huffy look) the two of them are making their way there.

As they walk toward the museum, Leo takes a second to look over at Eric, struck once again by how attractive he is. He might be buttoned-up, and he might be an asshole, but he has a certain confident swagger that Leo finds enticing.

He also smells good: a mixture of sandalwood and balsam and some faint spice he can’t identify but which seems to tickle the part of his brain tuned into male pheromones.

Stop it, he reprimands himself. This is Eric we’re talking about, not some Abercrombie & Fitch model.

To distract himself from all of this, he asks a question that’s always bugged him.

“Why are you such a skeptic? Not just about Mothman, but about everything. You seem like you don’t really believe in much of anything.”

The question seems to take Eric by surprise, but he recovers quickly, that infuriating smile appearing once again on his face.

“You know…I don’t really have a good answer to that question. I guess if I had to be honest about it, I’d say that I like making people defend their beliefs. A lot of people in my family were scientists, and they taught me to question everything. So…that’s what I do.”

He has to admit that that’s a good answer.

“Okay, fine,” he says. “But you don’t have to be such a jerk about it all the time.”

“I’ll take that under advisement,” Eric says, and before they can continue the conversation they've arrived at the museum.

Leo smiles as soon as he is in the place. He’s lost count of the number of times he’s come here, but each time is as magical as the last. It’s the Mecca for anyone who loves Mothman and everything associated with it. He smiles and waves at Mindy, the young woman working at the admission booth. He feels a bit generous, so he goes ahead and pays for Eric too, giving him a meaningful look as he does so.

He darts a look at his watch and sees that they’re going to be open for at least another hour, which gives him just enough time to see everything in the museum while making sure that he makes Eric suffer as much as possible. Judging by the long-suffering look on his face, he’s suffering a lot.

This’ll teach you to be such a jerk, Leo thinks smugly.

He ambles through the aisles of the museum, making sure to take as long as possible. He examines each artifact in minute detail–particularly the eyewitness testimonies from those who actually saw the Mothman back in the ‘60s, which have always fascinated him–always keeping Eric in sight as he does so. The more he meanders the more impatient Eric becomes, until he’s tapping his foot impatiently while standing against the wall.

As he wanders through the exhibits, Leo thinks fondly of the times that he spent with his first boyfriend, Max. They’d spend many hours in the TNT Area, reading books like The Mothman Prophecies and every old newspaper they could get their hands on, learning all about how the Mothman had supposedly appeared just before the Silver Bridge disastrously collapsed. They’d even managed to track down a few folks and talked to them about what they’d seen. Some were very much not reliable, but there were others who Leo believed actually saw what they said they saw.

Max had been the first person that Leo had given his heart and his body to, and he’d been stupid enough to believe that they were in it for the long haul. Sure, they were both young and in high school but, Leo thought, if the straights could marry their high school sweethearts, then why couldn’t gay folks? Those were some of the happiest days of his life, ones in which he was truly content.

And the sex was pretty great, too.

Until, of course, it all came to an end. Max decided that he wasn’t gay, after all. He said he wanted nothing further to do with Leo, cutting him off entirely. Max eventually moved out of town after his parents died, and the last thing Leo heard was that he’d married and had kids. Even now, these many years later, Leo carries the scars of their failed relationship. He’s let other men into his heart and shared his body with a few of them, but none of them have owned as much of him as Max.

Still, he’s held onto his love of Mothman, both because it still fascinates him and because it reminds him of one of the happiest times in his life. Maybe, he thinks, believing in the creature is his way of staying connected with Max, despite the distance between them.

Or maybe he’s just delusional.

Finally, Leo knows that he can’t keep putting off the moment of going to the TNT Area. A part of him has been hoping that Eric would give up on the whole idea and that he’d be able to take his little pilgrimage on his own without any company, but that’s becoming less and less likely by the moment.

How do I get myself into these situations? Leo asks himself. I could have just told him that I wanted nothing more to do with him and this whole mess would have been over. But I couldn’t just do that, could I? I had to make my own life much more difficult.

“Well,” Eric says, seeming to read his mind, “I’d say it’s just about time that we head out of here, huh? We’ve been browsing the festival for at least a couple of hours. No offense, but I’m starting to get a little bored.”

“Consider much offense taken,” Leo  snaps. “For your information, I’m not done yet.”

But, of course, he doesn’t really have much choice in the matter because it’s almost five, and the museum is getting ready to close. Eric clearly knows this too, based on the knowing grin plastered across his face.

“You know, you can keep trying to throw me off, but I’m going to see this through no matter what you do,” Eric says. “I have a lot more patience than you think I do.”

Leo curses to himself. He was afraid of that.

Finally, he can’t put it off any more. “I guess we can go,” he says, quite surly. “I hope you appreciate what I’m giving up for you.”

Eric gives a meaningful look at the museum, which by now is quite empty.

“Oh yeah, it definitely looks like we’re going to be missing out on a lot here.”  

Leo chooses not to respond to that.

“So, whose car shall we take?” Eric asks “Yours or mine? I’m happy with either.”

Leo pauses as he tries to think through that. He’s not sure which he likes less, the idea that Eric will be in his car or that he’ll be in Eric’s. He tends to like everything just so when it comes to his personal spaces, and that includes his car. Having someone like Eric inside of it…well, that’s just not something that he thinks he could ever be comfortable with.

Leo is one of those people who doesn’t like to feel that he’s out of control, yet that’s exactly what he feels any time that he’s in Eric’s presence. It’s as if the other man has a supernatural ability to make him self-conscious about himself, questioning every gesture he makes, wondering if that’ll be the moment that Eric finally lets the nice mask slip and starts making fun of him.

He thinks he would truly snap if that happened.

You have only yourself to blame, he says to himself. You didn’t have to agree to this little mission.

“I guess we’ll take yours,” he says grudgingly. If Eric is perplexed or annoyed by this he gives no sign of it.

“I have to get some stuff out of my car first, though,” Leo says.

Once again, he just gets a shrug for an answer, and he glares at Eric for a minute before they step out into the afternoon sun, waving at the museum attendees as they do so.

People from out of town tend to think that it's easy to get to the TNT Area, that all you have to do is just…drive and you’ll be there. They seem to think that it’s basically some sort of city park or the equivalent. The truth, though, is that it’s quite a trek to get there, and even just getting to the parking area is just the beginning. You then have to hike through the woods until you get to the actual area where all of the bunkers are.

Given all of that, Leo’s glad that he was smart enough to pack the right kind of equipment, which he gets out of his car and puts into the back of Eric’s. To his surprise, he sees that Eric has also come prepared. There’s everything in his trunk that a person could need for a night out in the wilderness: a tent, hiking boots, some pots and pans. There’s even stuff to make S’mores.

“What?” Eric asks, when he sees Leo looking at him with some surprise. “Did you really think that I was going to propose going off into the woods without at least making sure that I had the right equipment?”

That was, in fact, exactly what Leo has been thinking, but he doesn’t say that outloud. His face, though, seems to suggest the truth, because Eric just shakes his head.

“You really shouldn't make assumptions about people,” he says finally. “Because you know what assuming does.”

Leo wants to snap that he’s not in grade school any more and doesn’t need to be reminded of the dangers of assuming and being turned into an ass, but something stops him. Maybe it’s the fact that he’s slowly coming to realize that Eric isn’t the asshole he thought, or maybe it’s just the excitement of being back in the TNT Area, but something has put him in an unexpectedly good mood for the first time today. In fact, he can actually say that he feels happy, and that doesn’t happen particularly often, not even in the autumn.           

“Let’s get this show on the road,” he says, not quite willing to let go of the snark just yet. Eric might be charming, but he’s not that charming.

He’s briefly annoyed at how plain Eric’s car is on the inside–it doesn’t even have power windows–but then he just lets himself enjoy the sensation of letting someone else do the driving for once. It’s strange at first. Slowly but surely, though, he realizes it’s not actually that bad having someone else do the work. 

They don’t say much as they make their way up Route 62. They don’t even say that much when they get out of the car, and it’s only after they stand there for a few minutes that Leo finally breaks the silence.

“Well, are we just going to stand here all day looking at each other or are we actually going to try to get into the actual TNT Area before it gets dark?”

“Before we do any of that, we should decide whether we’re actually going to spend the night out here,” Eric says, pointing at the sign that says that, in fact, there are no camping facilities here at all. 

Leo scoffs. It’s such a thing for an out-of-towner to point out. Anyone who’s local knows that no one really cares whether people spend the night out there. Most of the people in charge of the area seem to think that if someone wants to spend their night amongst a bunch of old igloos then that’s their own foolishness.

“I don’t know about you, but I want to spend the night here.” He gives Eric a shy little smile. “It’ll be a little bit like It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown. I’m Linus, and I’m going to prove to you that Mothman exists.”

He of course has no idea whether the creature is going to show up, but he has to hold onto hope.

“Alright then,” Eric says, getting his equipment out of the back of the car. “Let’s go.”

Even though it’s September it’s still a humid day, and it’s even more sticky on the grounds of the TNT Area. That’s part of what has always made it so spooky to Leo.  He really could imagine some creature living here, growing more and more feral with each passing year. Despite that, though, he feels a sense of calm settle over him as they start walking. He’s always more comfortable in places like this, out in the woods where he doesn’t have to try to contend with people and their expectations.

They walk in a strangely comfortable silence for a bit, until they come to one of the paths that Leo always uses when he comes here. All of a sudden a deer bounds across their path, though Eric is too distracted to notice, gazing off into the distance rather than watching where he’s going. 

“Wait,” Leo whispers and reaches out a hand. Without meaning to it brushes Eric’s, and it’s as if an electric charge races up his arm. He quickly jerks his hand back and ducks his head, aware as he does so that he’s blushing at least a dozen different shades of red.

Fortunately it only takes a minute for his embarrassment to mostly pass, and when he looks back up Eric is looking at him, one eyebrow raised.

Leo puts a finger to his lips and points to where he saw the deer. It’s still standing there, its soft brown eyes looking at them. It’s a nine-point buck, and Leo thinks dimly that his dad would be overjoyed if he was here.

I’m glad he isn’t, though, he thinks. Something that beautiful should just be able to live without being hunted.

The deer gazes at them for a moment more, and then it bounds off, flicking its white tail behind it.

“Wow,” Eric says once the deer is out of sight, “that was really something, wasn’t it?” There’s such a look of wonder on his face that Leo finds himself actually liking him, as strange as that sounds.

“My uncle would have loved to see something like that,” Eric goes on.

“Is he a big hunter?”

Eric shakes his head. “I know you’re probably going to scoff and call me some sort of soft city boy, but he’s like me. He prefers to study the natural world rather than hunt it.” He holds his hands up as if expecting an attack. “It’s not that he doesn’t believe in hunting or anything like that. We both think that it’s a good thing, particularly given how quickly deer reproduce. It’s just…I don’t know. I kind of like the idea of just letting creatures enjoy the wild where they live without always having to worry about a human being coming in with guns blazing.”

Leo frowns. “I don’t think I like how much you’re sabotaging the image I had of you in my head.”

Eric just shrugs. “Well, that’ll teach you to have an attitude about someone that you don’t really know.”

“Oh, I don’t know,” Leo responds, deciding to go ahead with what he was about to say despite the fact that he knows it could sabotage this otherwise quite nice moment. “I tend to take a pretty dim view of people who go out of their way to make fun of the residents of their home state. After all, it’s not as if everyone has to be a cynic like you.”

Eric’s face crinkles for a minute, as if he hadn’t really thought of things like that before.

“You know something? You’re right. I’ve actually been thinking a lot about that YouTube channel and what I’ve been doing. Not because of you,” he hastens to add, “but just because I had a crisis of conscience. It’s kind of why I asked you to come out here in the first place.”

Leo isn’t sure whether to be glad about Eric’s change of heart or disappointed that there was an ulterior motive to Eric’s asking him out here.

Don’t be a lovesick idiot.

“I guess it’s better late than never,” he says with at least a little bit of grace. “You probably should've come to that conclusion before you made fun of people, though.”

The person that Leo thought Eric was would have just smirked and told him to get over it. This Eric, though, the one that he’s coming to learn is much more complicated than he thought, instead just nods his head as if Leo has said the most profound thing in the world.

“You’re probably right. But sometimes realize things later than you should, and you just have to do the best you can to make amends.”

Leo doesn’t have anything clever or cutting to say to that, and so he changes the subject.

“Oh well, let’s get on with this. If we’re going to make the most out of this adventure we should at least get to one of the igloos.

In fact, they pass several as they trek further and further into the TNT Area, but for some reason Leo doesn’t feel the urge to stop at any of them. Instead he finds himself just wanting to savor this time with Eric, who’s showing a whole side he never knew existed. He’s also enjoying just being out in the wilderness of this part of the world, with its strange mix of peace and brooding menace.

There’s no place like home, he thinks with a smirk.

At last, though, they come to one of the old bunkers and stop. Leo isn’t sure why, except that it seems to call to him. There’s nothing in there–unlike some of the other former facilities, which are said to still contain TNT and God only knows what else–but even so, Leo has the feeling that there’s something in there, or perhaps there was something there. Either way, it’s not a feeling that he relishes. Or maybe he does.

It’s all very confusing.

Even more confusing are the feelings that he’s starting to have for the man next to him. Though he hates to admit it, there’s a part of him that wonders whether the feeling is mutual, whether there might even be a bit of a spark of romance.

You’re getting way ahead of yourself, he thinks, that cynical part of him starting to take control.

“It’s really kinda spooky, isn’t it?” Eric says into the silence. “Standing here, I can see why people would believe that there’s some sinister being that lives here.” He cracks that rakish smile that he always breaks out when is feeling nervous (Leo isn’t sure how he knows this, other than that he just has a feeling). “But then again, this whole place is creepy.”

Suddenly he steps over the threshold into the bunker, and all Leo can do is look after him with what he’s sure is a very stupid look on his face.

“Are you coming?” Eric says, holding out a hand. “Or is the true believer between us too scared to actually go into one of the bunkers?”

Leo wants to retort that of course he’s coming, he’s not a chickenshit, but the truth is…he kind of is. No matter how many times he’s come to the TNT Area, he’s never actually gone into the igloos. After all, it’s one thing to believe in the Mothman; it’s quite another to actually come close to seeing him (or her? Or they?) in the flesh.

The more that he looks at Eric’s face and imagines the smirk he’s going to have if Leo chickens out, though, the more he knows he’s just going to have to get over it and go in.

Taking a deep breath Leo does just that, stepping into the cool darkness.

“So,” Eric says, using his phone to scan the land in front of him, “do you really believe in the Mothman or is that something you say so that you can look cool on the internet?”

Leo’s pretty sure that he’s not saying that to be cruel, so he tries to respond in kind.

“This might come as a surprise to you, but there are people out there who aren’t ruthless cynics.”

“I was just asking a question,” Eric says a trifle defensively. “I know I’ve been a bit of a jerk in the past, but I really am trying to make amends and get to know you a little bit better.”

Leo has to admit that there’s some wisdom to that.

“Okay fine. Yes, I do believe in him. Do I believe that everything about him is true and that he is a harbinger of doom and all of that…well, that I’m not so sure about.”

“So what do you think he is?”

Leo isn’t sure that he likes where all of this is going.

“I’m…not really sure,” he says. He hates to admit this. Sometimes, though, you just have to admit when you don’t know something, no matter how frustrating it is to do so.

Eric doesn’t mock him or laugh. In fact, he keeps looking at him intently, as if he’s genuinely interested in what he has to say.

“Okay, well, do you have any thoughts? I mean, you have to have some theories, right?”

Leo does have a lot of theories, but no one in the real world has ever really wanted to hear about them. He’s tried talking about them with some of the staff at the museum and the folks who gather for the Festival, but even they seem to think that he’s a bit out there.

He’s thus a little hesitant to reveal so much of himself to Eric of all people. Perhaps, though, this is just the time to do that. When he sees that Eric looks as if he is actually listening and really wants to hear from him, he takes the plunge.

“I think that he's some sort of…spirit, I’d guess you’d call it…that’s been here for since who knows when. I think that he gets disturbed when things happen in his territory, whether that’s the collapse of the Silver Bridge back in ‘67 or the building of the TNT bunkers. When that happens, he comes out.”

It’s not nearly as eloquent as he would have liked, but it’s pretty much the truth.

Eric gives him a considering look for a minute and then shrugs.

“You know what? That’s about as reasonable a story as I’ve heard so far.”

“You really think so?”

“I do. Or, at least, that’s a more coherent explanation than some of the other things I’ve heard.”

He pauses, as if aware of just how dangerous this territory is.

Leo narrows his eyes. “Oh yeah? I imagine you’ve heard some doozies.”

Eric holds up his hands in surrender. “I already told you that I’m trying to be less cynical. I’m not going to walk into that trap, believe me.”

“You’re a lot smarter than I gave you credit for being,” Leo says.

Eric doesn’t say anything to that smartass remark, and so for several more minutes they just sort of stand inside the bunker, neither of them quite ready to break the silence. Then, to Leo’s utter surprise, Eric reaches out a hand and takes his hand. He fights the urge to yank it back, not because he doesn’t like the feel of the other man’s skin against his own but because he likes it too much. He both loves and hates being this vulnerable and intimate with someone.

“Is this okay?” Eric asks.

No, his mind says.

“Yes,” he says aloud. “It’s okay.”

They stand there for a few more minutes, neither of them wanting to break this spell or whatever it is that they’ve both managed to cast. Finally, though, the cold from the damp earth and concrete around them begins to seep into their skin, and Eric shivers.

“Do you need a jacket?” Leo asks.

Eric gives him a wry little smile.

“What’s this?” he asks, raising an eyebrow. “Is someone’s icy little heart melting at last?”

Leo immediately thinks that he’s made a mistake in being this vulnerable. He quickly pulls his hand back and stares intently into the distance.

Idiot! He yells at himself inside. You should have known better than to try to be nice to this jackass. He’s always going to try to make a fool out of you. Don’t forget that.

He almost jerks away when Eric puts his hand on his arm.

“Hey,” Eric says, voice gentle, soft, like the buzz of a bumblebee in the still night air. “I’m sorry. You were trying to be sweet, and I was being a jerk.”

Leo doesn’t say anything at first.

Eric doesn’t know–can’t know, because why would he?--how much it takes Leo to open up like he did, little as must seem to him.

“We should go and set up camp,” he says. “It’s already starting to get dark.”

He ducks out of the bunker before Eric can say anything and starts looking around for somewhere dry enough to put their tent and start a fire. It’s lucky that it’s been the perfect autumn for such things: there’s been just enough rain to make sure a fire isn’t likely but still dry enough to mean that they didn’t have to pitch a tent in a puddle. Within a relatively short time they’ve got a nice fire going and the tent set up.

Eric is full of surprises, and he quickly shows that he knows what he’s doing when it comes to the outdoors, that all of that equipment wasn’t just for show. Leo does his best to help, but mostly he just tries to stay out of the way.

“I told you that my uncle was an outdoorsman,” Eric says to Leo’s unspoken question. “He used to take me camping when I was a kid. I guess I haven’t forgotten a lot of what he told me.”

As night draws down around them and the air fills with the sounds of crickets and katydids and frogs (among other things that Leo doesn’t quite recognize, despite having spent many nights out here), they roast hot dogs and make pizza using bread and mozzarella and sauce and pepperoni, all slapped together in a pie iron and held over the fire. They top it all off with S’mores. 

It’s the best night Leo’s had in a long time and, as the flames cast shadows on Eric’s face, he finds his earlier nervousness melting away, replaced with other, more exciting feelings.

He isn’t quite what it is that makes him actually become brave enough to reach out and place his hand gently on Eric’s. One thing he does know, though, is that he doesn’t regret.

Maybe I’m growing as a person, after all, he thinks wryly.

When Eric shifts slightly he tries not to flinch, but he can’t quite help it. He fully expects that he is going to jerk his own hand back in revulsion, particularly given the way their last intimate moment ended. To his surprise, though, Eric actually puts his own hand over Leo’s, and when he dares to look up he sees a shy little smile on the other man’s face. 

This can’t be happening. This can’t be real, he thinks. There’s no way that I’m sitting here in the TNT Area hunting Mothman with my worst online enemy. There’s certainly no way that we’re holding hands.

But it is happening, and before he can think better of it or tell himself that what he’s about to do is a mistake he’s reaching up the other hand to cup Eric’s face in his own. And then he’s leaning in for a kiss.

For a split second he thinks that he feels some hesitation on Eric’s part, as if he’s finally decided that enough is enough and it’s time to pull the plug on this charade. Then their lips meet, and all doubts that either of them might have had are suddenly going right out the window, as if they never existed at all.

Eric’s mouth tastes sweet, his lips meeting Leo’s with their own intensity. It’s been so long since Leo has been kissed like this that he’s almost forgotten the rhythms of how to be with someone else. As they continue to make out, though, and their hands start roaming over one another’s bodies, all of the old muscle memory comes back, and he starts to relax and just go with it, even though there’s a little voice in the back of his head that’s telling him to pull back before it’s too late.

That voice disappears, though, as the making out gets more intense and their hands find more places on one another’s bodies to explore. There’s a very prominent bulge in Eric’s pants that Leo is dying to get his hands on, but he’s not sure whether he has it in him to take that next step.

Luckily Eric does, and Leo can’t help but moan softly and thrust against Eric’s eager hand.

“Someone’s excited,” Eric teases, but the fondness in his voice takes the sting out of it.

Leo is, in fact, very eager, but he feels a little lost, uncertain of how to proceed. It’s not that he doesn’t like sex, of course. In fact, he really, really likes sex, but as with the kissing, it’s now been so long since he did it that he’s not sure he can remember where things go or how things go after this.

Once again, Eric comes to the rescue.

“Do you want to, um, take this further?” he asks. “I came prepared.” He fumbles around in his nearby pack and brings out condoms and lube.

“You brought condoms and lube out into the middle of nowhere?” Leo asks incredulously. He narrows his eyes. “Were you planning on trying to seduce me all along?” He’s not sure how he feels about that possibility.

Eric, however, once again shows that there’s a surprisingly soft side to him when he wants there to be.

“You don’t always have to be so suspicious,” he says. “Let’s just say that I like to be prepared for any contingency.” He shrugs nonchalantly. “After all, you never know when you’re going to meet some prickly Mothman believer and want to get in his pants.”

“And what makes you think I’m a bottom?” Leo asks. He doesn’t really want to keep putting up this fight, particularly not when Eric is so obviously interested in him, but he can’t quite shake the nerves, either.

Eric, with that irritating ability he has of reading Leo’s mind–or maybe just his body language–reaches out and cups Leo’s face.

“We don’t have to do this if you don’t want to,” he says. “I would never want you to do anything that makes you feel uncomfortable.” One corner of his mouth quirks in that rakish smile. “And I don’t know that you’re a bottom, or whether you’re a top. I’m vers, so it ultimately doesn’t matter to me either way. Whatever you want to do, we can do. There’s no rush or requirement.”

Leo has a snide remark ready for that, too, but somehow it doesn’t make it out. Instead what comes out is, “I don’t know why you’re so nice. I don’t really deserve it.” He pauses. “And I’m a vers-bottom, for what it’s worth.”

Again, that smile that’s so dazzling that it almost takes Leo’s breath away.

“I’d say that’s worth quite a lot.”

There’s a slight pause before Eric says, “Should we uh, you know, go into the tent? I think it’s a bit too cold out here, don’t you?”

“It’s like our own Appalachian Brokeback Mountain,” Leo blurts out.

“How did you know that was my favorite movie?” Eric asks.

“Just call it a sixth sense,” Leo says, and then they’re making out again, basically tearing at each other’s clothes as they finally make their way inside the tent.

Once they’re inside the tent they’re back at it but, just as Eric starts to take Leo’s shirt off, he puts up a hand to stop him.

“Is everything okay?”

He tries to think about how to tell Eric about his own issues with his body, about how he doesn’t always like showing it to other people.

If you’re going to do this, you might as well go all in. He’s not sure where that voice of confidence comes from but, strangely, it makes him feel confident enough to go through with this. Something about this night makes him feel like he’s on the cusp of something new, that all he has to do is take this last fateful step and somehow everything will be okay.

 “Yeah,” he says, “I’m good. You can proceed.”

Eric does.

It’s not long before they’re both totally naked, their bodies twined around each other. Eric is even more beautiful naked than he was with his clothes on. He has what Leo would define as a runner’s body, lean and toned rather than bulky, with a dusting of hair on his well-defined chest. Leo loves running his hands through it, savoring the way the hairs gently scratch his skin.

“You’re beautiful,” Eric says suddenly. Leo blushes, not used to getting complaints about his appearance and thus not knowing how to respond.

“I mean it,”  Eric says, pressing a passionate kiss on his lips. “Beautiful and sexy and hot. I can’t wait to ravish you.”

“Then what are you waiting for?” Leo blurts out, partly because he is eager to know what it feels like to have Eric inside him and partly because he’s not comfortable with having so many compliments lavished on him at once.

“Your wish is my command,” Eric says, and then flips him over so that he’s on his back, his legs in the air.

“You okay?” he asks.

“Yes,” Leo says. 

Eric takes a few minutes to prepare Leo, first with his tongue and then with his fingers. Leo tries at first to hold back the moans, but then they’re coming out of his mouth, faster and faster as Eric picks up the pace with his fingers. Then there’s a pause as he opens the condom and puts it on, the soft wet sound of the lube, and then Leo feels Eric’s cock pressed up against him. 

“Well?” he demands. “Are you going to put it in or what?”

Eric shakes his head and laughs softly but, to be fair, he does just as Leo asks. He isn’t huge, but he’s big enough that it takes Leo a few minutes to get used to his length and girth. Eric, though, is also a very attentive lover, and he pauses every few minutes to make sure that Leo is okay.

After about the third such inquiry, however, Leo does snap just a bit. “You don’t have to keep checking on me,” he says. “I’m not some delicate piece of china that’s going to break all to pieces if you fuck me too hard.”

Eric grins at him, and there’s something just a bit demonic about it. Leo gets the feeling that he might have bitten off more than he could chew. However, he’s also excited about this, excited about the way that the two of them already seem to fit together so well, excited about the way that Eric just seems to understand how his body works, in some ways even better than he knows himself.

Then Eric starts to pick up the pace of his thrusts, and Leo loses himself to the rhythms of the sex. Usually when he has sex with someone his mind still races along, thinking about all of the things that could go wrong. This time, though, it’s as if is just totally one with his body, and with Eric’s, and with the desire and the pleasure and the passion that thrums between them.

In between kissing him passionately, Eric whispers sweet things into Leo’s ears. Some of it’s nonsense, of course–the usual strings of “fuck fuck fuck” and “goddamn” that are always part of sex–but there are other things, too, confessions of how beautiful Eric thinks he is, how good it feels to be inside him, how much Eric enjoys spending this closeness with him. He talks a lot, but Leo strangely doesn’t mind. In fact, he kind of likes it.

The pleasure and the pressure continues to mount between the two of them, their breaths coming harder and faster, the climax building like some great force of nature. It almost feels like the world is expanding around him at every moment, until he’s one with…with everything. 

“Fuck,” Leo whispers, his face buried in Eric’s shoulder, “Eric, I don’t think I’m going to be able to go much longer. I…I think I’m going to come.”

Eric leans back and puts a hand behind Leo’s head, cradling him, while with his other he reaches out and gently pushes Leo’s hand away from his cock and replaces it with his own.

“Oooooh,” Leo whispers, eyes going wide at the pleasure that arcs through him, a jolt that almost feels like electricity. “Eric…Eric…that feels so good.” 

“I want you to come for me, baby,” Leo says softly, his eyes seeming to bore into his soul. “I want to see you come.”

The effortless command in Eric’s voice is enough for him. It drives him over the edge, and his orgrasm hits him like a tidal wave. He’s sure that if there is a Mothman lurking somewhere out in the darkness and the woods and the weeds, he almost certainly heard what just happened.

A second later Eric reaches his own climax, and the power of both of them coming at the same time is almost more than Leo can stand. 

And then it’s all over. The haze of sated desire hangs inside the tent and, for possibly the first time in his life, Leo is truly and unquestionably happy.

“That was great,” Eric says, laying down beside him and resting his head on Leo’s chest. “Really, really great.”

It’s such a simple statement. It means the world to Leo, though. He thinks briefly of Max, and of the times they shared together, but something about being so close to Eric makes him able to make peace with those sad memories in a way he’s never been able to do before.

“Yeah, it was,” he says and plants a soft kiss on the top of Eric’s head.

He thinks that maybe he should say something else, should make sure that Eric understands just how much what happened means to him. Before he can do that, though, Eric is asleep.

“Figures,” Leo says quietly. “You’re such a man.”

He smiles as he says it, though, and soon enough he’s asleep too.

 

Leo isn’t sure what it is that wakes him up, but as soon as his eyes open he knows that something isn’t right. For one thing the entire TNT Area seems to have gone eerily quiet. Whereas before there were all of the sounds one might expect of a place like this–frogs croaking off in the water, night birds warbling, other sounds that he couldn’t identify and didn’t want to think about too much–now there’s nothing at all, just…silence. It’s eerie and, as it stretches on, the eerie turns into downright terrifying.

“Eric,” he whispers. “I think something’s wrong out there.”

Eric just mumbles and doesn’t really start to wake up, at least not until Leo digs at his ribs with an insistent finger.

“Eric, wake up. I think something’s really wrong.”

Maybe it’s the tone in his voice, or maybe it’s just the fact that he senses that something is wrong, too, but he suddenly lurches up.

“What’s going on?” he asks, a note of panic.

“I just told you. I think something’s outside.”

Neither of them have to say what it is that he thinks is out there.

Mothman.

“Well, I guess we might as well go out there and see,” Eric says with his usual brash confidence. “I mean, if it is him, or it, or whatever Mothman is, then there’s no point in us being in here, since we came all the way out here to get evidence that he exists.”

The words are tumbling out of his mouth so fast that he can barely form them into a coherent sentence. Leo, though, finds himself agreeing with him, even if he’s also scared shitless.

They put their clothes on as hurriedly as they’d torn them off just a short time ago and stumble out into the night, Eric with a flashlight in his hand and Leo with a big stick that he happens to see lying on the ground. He has no idea what good it’s going to do if Mothman is out there, but he figures it’s better than nothing.

For a few seconds they stand there, both of them trying to catch their breaths and casting the flashlight everywhere they can. Then they both hear a rustling in the bushes off to their right and they turn as one, their hands clutched so tightly that it’s almost painful.

And they see the Mothman.

There’s no way that it could be anything else, that much Leo knows at once. He’s read every single news report that’s ever been released about what it looks like and how it behaves. The thing standing there in the beam of the flashlight is easily seven feet tall if not taller, its wings spread out to either side of it like great billows of shadow. Even in the light, however, it seems to flicker in and out of focus, as if it’s not entirely of this world. Only its eyes seem to gleam with a terrible power, in shades of red and blue and violet.

“I can’t believe this,” Eric says, fumbling for his phone. “I just can’t believe this.”

Neither can Leo, if he’s being honest with himself. At first he thought that it might be someone in a costume, someone who saw them come in here and decided that it would be fun to fuck with them. However, the total quiet from all of the other things in the woods, combined with the bone-deep chill that’s filled the air, tells him that this isn’t a fake or a ruse or a trick. This is the real deal, and he is almost losing his mind because he’s so scared and excited. He doesn’t know how to process all of it.

Nothing is ever going to be the same after this, he thinks. He knows all the stories about how the Mothman’s ability to seemingly predict disaster. What if that’s what he’s doing right now? What if this is a sign from the universe that this whole thing with Eric is a giant mistake?

Or what if, instead, the Mothman is just a harbinger of change. Maybe, after all, he doesn’t have to be something bad. It’s a realization so basic that it strikes Leo like a bolt of lightning out a clear blue sky. He wonders if Eric is thinking the same thing, but he doesn’t dare take his eyes of Mothman to see. 

And then, as quickly as the Mothman appeared, he’s gone, and the two of them are left alone in that little clearing, already starting to wonder whether what they saw was the real thing or whether they’d dreamed it all.

“So…are we going to talk about what we just saw, or are we going to pretend that didn’t happen?” Eric’s voice seems almost too loud in the silent aftermath of Mothman’s appearance. Leo wants to tell him to speak more quietly, but he’s having trouble finding his own voice, which seems to have run somewhere where he can’t find it.

“Did you hear what I said, Leo?” Eric asked.

“I…I did,” he manages at last. “And I don’t really have an answer. I can honestly say that I never expected in a thousand years to actually see the real Mothman. It’s…it’s like nothing.”

He realizes as soon as he says it how inadequate the words are. Since he can’t think of anything better to say he just…doesn’t say anything at all. Instead he works alongside Eric to get the tent packed up and put away, making sure that the fire has been raked over and water poured on it, that everything is put back together in such a way that no one would ever know they were there.

They remain largely quiet as they make their way out of the TNT Area. There’s so much behind them, so many things that passed in that little space of time, how could they ever do something so banal as to put their feelings into words? At first the quiet is of the peaceful kind, the kind that exists between two people who are utterly comfortable with one another. With each minute, though, Leo’s sense of discomfort grows as he begins to wonder whether he’s done or said something wrong, whether whatever magic was beginning to sprout himself and Eric has been snipped off at the root. 

Things don’t get any less awkward when they come to Eric’s car, and it only grows more oppressive as they make the short drive back to Point Pleasant. By this point the sun is out and the day has already begun, though even on a weekday the little town isn’t particularly busy. A few cars make their way down Main Street, a few people going in and out of the shops. Everything looks so…normal. How can that be, when everything about Leo’s life is different than it had been just a day before?

When they come up alongside Leo’s car Eric puts his own into park. Neither of them has said anything since the few minutes after they saw Mothman, so now it almost seems as if nothing could break the silence. Maybe this is it. Maybe they’ll end up going their separate ways and never seeing each other again.

Somehow they both agree to get out of the car at the same time, and for a few awkward seconds they stand outside, neither of them still quite willing to say anything just yet. Whatever it is that they’ve formed during their little encounter–whether it’s a romance or whether it’s a fling or something else–neither of them is in a rush to define it or to speak about what they’ve seen.

Unsurprisingly, it’s Eric who decides to break the silence. As Leo is rapidly learning, there’s nothing that he hates more than just being quiet. It’s one of the things that he finds both endearing and irritating about him.

“So, not to get all serious with you but…what are we now? Are we gonna just act like none of this–the Mothman, the hand-holding, the sex–ever happened and go on about our lives? I don’t know about you, but I don’t want that to be the case. I…,” he pauses, clearly searching for the right series of words, “well, I like you a lot, Leo. And I kind of think that Mothman was a sign. If that’s not enough to make two enemies turn into lovers, then what is?”

Leo almost feels tempted to scoff at the romance novel cliche, but he doesn’t. Instead, he looks out at the Ohio River. He’s not sure what he should say, or even what he wants to say, and he hates feeling that way. He wants to run away back to his own house, burrow down in the covers, and hope that he can eventually figure out what to say from the safety of the internet.

No, he says, You’re not going to do that. You’re going to talk to him and work through your feelings, one way or another.

“I guess we could…stay in touch and maybe do this again sometime?” he says. He doesn’t like that he turned that last bit into a question.

Eric looks a bit disappointed, but then his dorky face turns into a smile. Leo hates how much he loves it when his face does that.

“I think I’d like that a lot,” Eric says.

Leo puts his hands on his hips. “You think? After we…well, after we did what we did out in the woods and after we saw the Mothman, you’re going to just say sometimes. Honestly, what was the point of all of this?”

Before Leo can say anything else Eric comes over to his side of the car, leans in, and plants a very generous and intimate kiss on his lips, drawing back with a true shit-eating grin on his face.

“I hate you, you know that?” Leo snaps. “I meant everything I said in the comments section of your stupid videos. I’m going home right now, and I’m never going to speak to you again.”

He knows quite well that he doesn’t mean a word of what he’s saying right now, and Eric clearly knows that, too.

“Sure you did,” Eric says, giving him that crooked smile. “Come on. Let me get you some breakfast, and then I’ve got to hit the road.”

They visit Leo’s favorite downtown dining spot. Even though he knows that there’s no way Eric could know this, somehow it feels appropriate. He’s been there so often that the waitress already knows what he wants. A short time later they’re both chowing down on waffles and home fries and eggs and sausage.

Apparently seeing a cryptid and having sex in the woods makes you really hungry, Leo thinks with a smile.

“What are you thinking about?” Eric asks.

“I was just thinking about what a special night last night was. About how I don’t think either of us are ever going to be the same. About how wild it is that I had sex in the TNT Area and saw Mothman. You know, if this were a horror movie we both would have died this morning.”

That seems to cast a bit of a pall over breakfast. Then Eric smiles, and it’s all okay again.

“I think I’ve discovered a new passion project.” When Leo raises a quizzical eyebrow he goes on. “From now on I’m not going to be a skeptic. I’m going to hunt down true believers and interview them for my podcast. In fact, I think that’s what I’m going to call my new channel, ‘In Search of True Believers.’ What do you think?”

“I think it sounds like a great ideal. It’ll go a long way toward making amends.”

There’s an ease to their conversation now, as if the earlier icy silence has thawed into a springtime  flourishing. The old Leo would have been terrified of speaking so much but now, oddly, he feels light, buoyant, happy.

“I’d…I’d like it if you might think about being my co-host,” Eric says.

Once again, the old Leo would have balked at that and gone running. The new Leo, though, gives a shy little smile and says, “Really? I’d like that, too.”

It’s not a guarantee of a future together. Hell, it’s not even a guarantee of a second date. But Leo has learned that in life there are no guarantees, and that you have to take the happiness where you can find it.

They hold hands as they walk back to Eric’s car, even though they get a few hostile glances while doing so. A lot has changed, but they’re still in West Virginia and, much as Leo loves his home, it still has a long way to go.

They share one last kiss as Eric gets inside and starts up the engine, rolling his window down.

“I’ll see you soon, okay Leo?” he says. Whereas once he was caustic and more than a little cruel–or at least his online persona was–now he’s solicitous and kind. It’s a change Leo likes to see, and he thinks that maybe this part of Eric was there all along.

“You definitely will,” Leo says and then, being braver than usual, he leans in for another kiss, this one with tongue.

Then Eric is headed out of town, and Leo watches the car until it disappears around a curve of the road, then he stands there for several more minutes after that. His heart feels oddly full but not heavy. He feels like the future is open for anything.

“Well,” he says. “That about does it.”

Getting in his own car he starts driving away and, just as he crosses out of town, he thinks he sees a winged shape go swooping off into the trees beside the road. He smiles.

“Thanks, buddy,” he says, and heads on home.

The proud son and grandson of farmers and coal miners, TJ West is a queer writer and culture critic and the author of Country Road Romance, Hittin' the Right Note, and A Bond of Blood and Stone. He holds a Bachelor’s degree from Marshall University and a Master’s and Doctorate from Syracuse University. Though he is based on Maryland’s Eastern Shore–where he lives with his partner and their cat–the Mountain State will always have a piece of his heart.

Next
Next

“Three Years and Counting,” Art, Nada Anwar Rajab